I hope it’s okay that I am using a friend of mine’s question that he brought up in my last entry. It is actually a really great segue into the next part of my spiritual journey. I brought this question up earlier:
Would God create a Church where he desired us to be in disunity, even about the smallest of things?
My friend, Jeremy, asked me to expound upon this, and this was my answer:
“I believe this is a question that all Christians should ask themselves. It seems simple, but at the heart of the issue is biblical interpretation. How was Scripture interpreted in the early Church? Who interpreted it? Was it the Church or individuals? What was the result, and what did the early Church believe and teach? The fact is, for hundreds and hundreds of years, the Church was unified because Christians believed that Christ gave authority to the Church to teach and interpret Scripture. Fast forward to the Reformation and after: Individual interpretation becomes prevalent, and thus we have thousands and thousands of denominations because of people becoming dissatisfied with their sect of Christianity saying “I don’t agree with that,” or “The Holy Spirit doesn’t guide ME to believe that way…” A new group is formed, and the process repeats. It’s still happening today. The Church essentially bought into a secular individualism that destroyed Christian unity (not completely). So, my point is, if Christ desired us to be in unity (which I think we all can agree to that), then that means that there has to be a Church where we can be in unity. We must seriously look at the early Church, the pioneers of our Faith, study and understand what they taught and believed, and ask ourselves how this applies to us today.”
In short, the answer is “no,” God does not desire for his Church to be torn apart, yet that’s what we have. I began to really ponder this. I researched the early Church, what they wrote, what they believed, what they taught. I won’t go into specifics now; I’ll save that for future posts. But, the fact is, early Church teaching points to Roman Catholic theology. Did early Church Fathers believe in: Infant Baptism? Check. True Presence in the Eucharist? Check. The true meaning of “the communion if Saints?” Check. And many, many other doctrinal positions. Why is this important?
These were the Spirit-led Christian men who assembled the books of the New Testament. These men, these teachers and theologians whom we trusted through the power of God to put together the Holy Scriptures believed ^these^ things. The New Testament (which is the same for Protestants and Catholics) was canonized somewhere around 400 AD. 400 years of Christianity existed before that. This was only a few generations removed from the actual time of Jesus.
The early Church was given the authority from Christ to teach and interpret Scripture, not the individual Christian believer. The Bible says that “the gates of Hell shall not prevail” against the Church.
To me, it was important to really examine what these men believed if I was going to trust that the New Testament which I believe is 100% infallible, was assembled by them. I am not saying that these men were infallible, but Christianity was unified in belief at this time. There was ONE Faith, and this one Faith believed the previously mentioned dogma. The next question I had to answer: What Church looks like this today?
…
And thus, I found myself in a nearly one year battle, wrestling with the idea of becoming Catholic. I prayed HARD about what God’s will was for me. I sought advice from pastors, priests, friends, family, authors… but when it came down to it, I knew where I was being called. God was leading me to the Catholic Church.
I dropped hints to my friends and family. I was ready for someone to talk me out of it, but the circular reasoning of Protestantism never satisfied my yearning for truth. There was a period of about a month between when I decided I would start RCIA, and when I actually told someone that. (Rite of Christian Initiation for Adults is the process by which one fully comes to understand the Catholic Church and her teachings, similar to but not exactly like the Protestant equivalent of membership classes.) This month was one of the most trying periods of my life. I didn’t want to leave behind the richness of my Protestant Faith. I am sure this was in part due to a certain amount of comfort I had there, but I think even more so, it was due to the “problems” I saw in me becoming Catholic. At this point, I was theologically Catholic, so that wasn’t the issue. My mind was there, my heart was not. I was going to miss southern gospel music, Fanny Crosby, the Wesleys, extemporaneous prayer, potlucks, hymn sings, campmeetings, my “evangelical” spirit, Alistair Begg, and sooo much more.
I know, this seems trite, especially to cradle Catholics. But these things were (and still ARE) a very important part of me. I shared what I was thinking with a priest that I spoke to during this time period. His response was not what I expected. He said simply:
Bring all of that with you. We need it.
Whoa. You mean, I don’t have to leave everything behind? My heart was convinced. My mind was convinced. Years, prayers, talks, books, fights 🙂 and many tears later, on December 14, 2011, I met with Renee at Communion of Saints Parish, and shared with her my desire to become Catholic. I started the RCIA process on January 9, 2012. I was confirmed and received Eucharist on April 7. My first full day as a Catholic was April 8, Easter Sunday.
After years of journeying, I was finally Home.
—————————————————
I wrestled with many of the big differences in Protestant and Catholic theology. It was not an easy process. I chose not to go into detail about this in my previous entries. I would like to tackle these things separately, and give them each an entry or two of their own. Baptism, Eucharist, Confession, just to name a few.
I will close with this: I, as a Roman Catholic, live solely for the glory of God. I cling to the mysterious and unfathomable love of God. I am saved by the amazing grace of Jesus Christ.
And this relationship requires my daily conversion.